These LGBTI Jews reflect on their history for Holocaust Remembrance Day

'Jewish Existence is Resistance,' reads Ariel Sobel's Women's March sign

Today (27 January) marks Holocaust Remembrance Day. With the rise of anti-Semitism across the US and Europe, LGBTI Jews are reflecting on the legacy of the Holocaust and why it matters today.

Anti-Semitism today

According to a recent report, one in 20 British people deny the Holocaust even happened. State-side, FBI data shows a rise in anti-Semitic hate crimes between 2016 and 2017. In New York City specifically, hate crimes targeted Jewish people more than all other groups combined in 2018.

What it means for LGBTI Jews

‘I feel sad on this day. We have not come far enough,’ 31-year-old queer Jew going by the pseudonym Switch tells GSN.

‘We, as LGBTQ+ Jews, still live in fear. We are still faced with the denials of rights, we are faced with hate and ignorance and intolerance.’

‘This day should show us how far the world has come,’ they continue. ‘Not how far it still must go. We shouldn’t have to live in fear. Never again should mean never again… for all of us.’

Nazi views on LGBTQ lives

‘I think it’s important to acknowledge that the Nazis basically started their intellectual purge by getting rid of “degenerate” books and art, which meant stuff by LGBTQ people, stuff about LGBTQ people, [and] the whole library of early research on trans people,’ Miriam, a Jewish lesbian, tells GSN.

‘However, it’s also essential, in my opinion, with young goyish [non-Jewish] queers claiming the shit out of Shoah because “the Nazis killed queer people” to remember that the Nazis mostly didn’t give a fuck about actually killing queers who weren’t members of other targeted categories.’

Miriam references Ernst Röhm and Edmund Heines, two gay men who were still part of the Nazi ranks.

‘In short, being gay wasn’t going to get you sent to the camps or kicked out of the Nazi Party,’ Miriam states. ‘Being a queer Jew, or a queer Roma, or a disabled queer was actually how people were winding up branded as homosexual or antisocial. Not just being queer.’

Miriam also notes the Nazis ‘didn’t recognize gay women as a real thing and considered lesbianism to be a kind of antisocial behavior.’

Holocaust Remembrance

Ariel Sobel, a 23-year-old queer Jewish writer, feels the same way as Miriam.

‘As a member of the Jewish and LGBTQ communities, I think it’s important to remember that the Holocaust gave the Jewish people intergenerational trauma that today’s queer people do not suffer from,’ she says.

Rivkah Standig, a 30-year-old queer Jewish woman, also agrees with this analysis.

‘I often feel like LGBTQ people who are otherwise not marginalized almost appropriate the Holocaust,’ she says. ‘As a queer Jew, my Jewish identity is the one that hurts most and is most affected by the Holocaust.’

‘In many ways, I feel like the world wants to universalize the Holocaust. But it wasn’t universal, it was specific,’ Standig continues. ‘There were specific groups targeted. Being gay wouldn’t necessarily outright land you in a concentration camp unless you also belonged to one of the other marginalized groups such as Jews, disabled people, or Roma.’

‘I find it profoundly disrespectful to ignore that specificity and universalize the genocide of these groups. Our pain is passed down from generation to generation in a way that won’t occur by simply being born queer. It’s not the same.’

‘The Holocaust impacts every facet of Jewish life in a way that is fundamentally different than how it affects LGBTQ communities,’ Sobel adds.

See Also:

These are the stories of gay women in a Nazi concentration camp

Man yells ‘Heil Hitler, Heil Trump’ at Fiddler on the Roof production

The Holocaust is fading from people’s minds in the United States

Newly discovered pages of Anne Frank’s diary reveal her uncle was gay

Germany asks for ‘forgiveness’ for persecuting gays under Nazi rule

Author: Rafaella Gunz

The post These LGBTI Jews reflect on their history for Holocaust Remembrance Day appeared first on Gay Star News.

Gay Jewish owner of San Francisco civic engagement space faces weekly protests

The Lucy Parsons Project protesting outside of Manny's

Manny’s Cafe, a civic engagement space in San Francisco’s Mission District, has been facing an onslaught of protest.


Manny Yekutiel, the space’s owner, is the gay son of an Afghan refugee. He opened the doors to the community space in November 2016. Since then, it’s been a hub for cultural and intellectual discourse. It has been a host to speakers from many social justice causes, including Black Lives Matter. Visitors are also welcome to peruse the space’s bookstore for titles from authors like Ta-Nehisi Coates and Howard Zinn. The food at the space is prepared daily by Farming Hope, a non-profit employing the homeless.

The protest

Still, this hasn’t stopped a San Francisco-based advocacy group The Lucy Parsons Project from demonizing the space. The group meets every Wednesday since December to protest Manny’s. The reasoning? Manny Yekutiel is a ‘Zionist gentrifier.’

The group’s signs include slogans like ‘Zionists out of the Mission,’ ‘Free Palestine,’ ‘Manny’s = homelessness,’ and more.

The Lucy Parsons Project describes themselves as a ‘radical black queer direct action group fighting anti-blackness in the Bay Area.’

This group has called on the public to ‘boycott Manny’s and its “woke-washing” of the Mission.’

In a letter to the media, the group said, ‘the proprietor of Manny’s, Emmanuel Yekutiel, has unequivocally espoused racist, Zionist, pro-Israel ideals that we will not tolerate or accept in our community. We will not tolerate gentrifiers and Zionists attempts at invading and destroying our community through “woke-washing!”’

In Manny’s own words

‘I worked on both the Obama and Clinton campaigns and, after 2016, was struck by the thirst for civic engagement. Here was a citizenry, with their hands raised, looking for a starting place for action and unsure of how to begin — that’s what 2016 inspired. Seeing this problem, I gathered a community to build a physical civic events space called Manny’s at the corner of 16th and Valencia streets in San Francisco,’ Yekutiel wrote in a recent op-ed in the San Francisco Chronicle.

‘We’ve had elected officials and advocates in the space, artists and poets and change-makers coming in to teach and to learn. The space is fulfilling a real need.’

‘Amid this remarkable coming-together of people from all walks of life, there also have been fringe activists who’ve gained an outsized voice demonizing Manny’s online. The far-right has attacked the business and me when they’ve disapproved of a guest speaker. The alt-left has pushed vitriolic lies and hatred on social media. Claims such as the space is a Zionist takeover of the Mission has emboldened people to walk in off the street and demand to know if the owner is Jewish.’

‘The building has been vandalized with anti-Semitic graffiti [and] is the target of weekly protests. The business has been ideologically extorted: tell us if you’re a Zionist so we can try to drive you out of business. Given the mission of Manny’s, we have invited these individuals into the space for dialogue, but their goal is to shut down discourse, not engage in it.’

Manny’s story

‘I’m a religious Jew and proud of it. My father escaped persecution in Afghanistan and journeyed, partly on foot, to Israel to reunite with family who had previously escaped oppression and found safety there. My little sister was almost blown up by a suicide bomber at a bus stop in Jerusalem,’ Yekutiel explains.

‘As a liberal American Jew, I have complicated feelings about Israel. I do not support everything that its government does (nor everything our American government does). Israel and the United States have provided my family with safety when other countries haven’t. But that doesn’t mean I support the ending of innocent life. My hope for the Israeli and Palestinian people is to soon live in peace with mutual recognition in sovereign and safe borders. This complex issue is a perfect example of the need for high-quality discourse.’

‘What bonds ideological absolutists on the left and the right is precisely what inspired the building of this new space — the opportunity to reverse corrosive incivility and to have vibrant discussion about complicated subjects,’ he says. ‘The ugliness of online discourse has made people hungry for the constructive in-person dialogue we are fostering at Manny’s.’

Anything else?

Manny Yekutiel is not the only liberal LGBTI Jew who has faced backlash due to assumed support of Israel. In 2017, Jewish lesbians were asked to leave the Chicago Dyke March because they had a Star of David on their Pride flag. The organizers deemed them ‘Zionist’ and thus unwelcome. Wendy Sue Biegeleisen, one of the founders of Dyke March, called the action anti-Semitic.

Author: Rafaella Gunz

The post Gay Jewish owner of San Francisco civic engagement space faces weekly protests appeared first on Gay Star News.